If you're unfamiliar with the situation, here is a thumbnail sketch: Ray Rice is a professional football player who was caught in video hitting his then fiancé (now wife) in an elevator. He was suspended for a few games and then later given an indefinite suspension which was overturned this week.
There are several principles at play in this situation. First of all, it is never acceptable to strike a woman. Ray Rice must be held accountable for his actions. We cannot be a society that allows violence, especially toward women, as a normal part of human interaction. If Ray Rice doesn't face any significant consequences, then we are signaling that entertainment value trumps human decency.
At the same time, we live in a culture that values second chances. As a follower of Christ, I belong to a kingdom built on grace and mercy, forgiveness and second chances.
So how do we balance the two?
Yes, Ray Rice should face appropriate consequences for his actions, and the opinions about those consequences are endless. However, should those consequences be permanent, without an opportunity for redemption and renewal?
At the end of day, I believe the best resolution to this issue cannot come from Roger Goodell, the NFL owners, other players, or even the fans. It must come from Ray Rice.
Ray, the ball is in your court. To use a football analogy, you have been handed the ball; where are you going to run?
Ray could run the victim direction, pleading to be signed to a team because he was unfairly punished. But I believe that sends the message that what he did wasn't that bad and everyone just needs to move on.
He could also go the entitlement route, reinforcing the idea that athletes and entertainers live by a different standard; as long as they win, off-the-field behavior is simply a distraction from what really matters.
There is a third option that could end in both redemption and renewal. Ray could admit he was wrong, apologize for his behavior, and commit to taking the rest of this season off to focus on his family and personal struggles.
This doesn't sweep it under the rug while also providing an opportunity for a second chance. It acknowledges that wrong that has been done, but gives the wrongdoer a chance to change, a healthy balance of justice and mercy, consequences and grace.
Ray could have a fresh start next season while making a statement about what really matters. With one simple but difficult decision, he could display humility and repentance, something that is sorely lacking in our society, especially amongst those who entertain us and often influence our children.
For those crying for justice, this may not be enough punishment. But Ray Rice isn't the first person whose violation of a societal standard brought forth condemnation and cries for punishment. Before you condemn Ray forever, remember the words of Jesus as he spoke to a crowd ready to stone a woman caught in the act of adultery: “Let any one of you who is without sin be the first to throw a stone.” (John 8:7 NIV)
But as Jesus stands in the midst of public opinion, he would not just speak to those holding a stone in their hand, ready to bring forth retribution. He would look squarely into the eyes of the man who was caught abusing his future wife and say, “Go now and leave your life of sin.” (John 8:11 NIV)
What's your move, Ray?
shine!
Jason